Pros and Cons of Stones vs. Mulch in Landscaping

“Is stone or mulch the right fit for my landscaping?”

When you walk around the neighborhoods of Upper Bucks, Montgomery, and Lower Lehigh Valley, it’s hard not to notice how homeowners creatively use stones or mulch to adorn their garden beds.

Your observation might spark a thought and cause you to wonder whether to use stone or mulch to spruce up your landscaping. So you can make the right decision for your home’s aesthetics, style, and budget, we’ll examine the pros and cons of both.

Stone in landscaping: pros and cons

Homeowners in Upper Bucks, Montgomery, and Lower Lehigh Valley derive several benefits from using stone in their landscaping. However, this choice is not without its downsides.

Pros of stone in landscaping

Durability - Stones are highly resistant to weather and foot traffic, making them very durable. You don’t have to replace them as frequently as mulch. They can also withstand fires and intense winds.
Low maintenance - Stones are also easy to maintain. They don’t require regular replenishment, unlike mulch.
Drains water better - Stones can help drain excess water, making them a better option in areas that hold water.

Cons of stone in landscaping

Higher initial cost - While they offer durability and retain their looks for a long time, the upfront cost of installing stones can be higher than mulch. However, this higher initial cost can be offset by their long lifespan.
Little soil improvement: Stones won’t break down and do not improve the soil with the addition of nutrients, unlike mulch.
Heat absorption - In hot weather, stones can absorb and radiate heat, which can be harmful to plants.

Mulch in landscaping: pros and cons

Many homeowners in Upper Bucks, Montgomery, and Lower Lehigh Valley have also opted for mulch because of the many advantages it offers. Despite its benefits, mulch does have some cons.

Pros of mulch in landscaping

Moisture retention - Mulch improves soil quality by retaining moisture, which can be helpful in dry periods.
Nutrient enhancement - As organic mulch, such as shredded hardwood, breaks down over time, it enriches the soil with beneficial nutrients.
Less expensive - Compared to stones, mulch is cheaper to source and install per yard, making it a more cost-effective option.
Weed suppression - Mulch acts as a natural weed barrier, reducing the need for chemical weed control.

Cons of mulch in landscaping

Need for replenishment - Since mulch breaks down over time, it needs replenishment to do its job efficiently.
Attracts pests - Mulch can attract insects and pests, requiring regular inspection to prevent infestation.
Harder to clean up - Mulch is lighter and can be easily carried away by wind, littering the environment. So, you may need to do regular clean-ups.

Whether it’s stone or mulch, trust the experts at Gerhart’s Landscaping Services

Depending on your landscaping goals, budget, style, taste, and other preferences, mulch can do wonders for your landscaping. And so can stone. Whether you choose stone or mulch, the right material can ensure that your outdoor space becomes a beautiful and functional extension of your home.

If you are not sure which to go for, we’ll be happy to help. As expert landscapers, we will guide you in making the right choice for your landscape. Contact us today.